PIZZA Shackamaxon

Matthew Schuster 2 months ago

I was a regular customer here and their pizza is pretty good. However the customer service is awful! On July 10th 2026 I ordered a pepperoni pizza and asked if they could leave like 2 slices plain for my 10 year old daughter. The manager/cashier responds by saying "we can do half and half." I say "I really only need about 2 plain slices." Then the guy making the pizzas "says are u serious bro well u can just buy some plain slices then." I honestly thought he was joking until they served me the pizza and there was only pepperoni on half of it. For a $30 pizza i do not understand what the big deal would have been to just leave a few slices plain? There's another review someone else wrote that said "that to cool to care attitude just doesn't work anymore in this day and age." I agree with that statement that is exsacty how these people are. They're are plenty of other pizza spots with pizza just as good or better that I will be bringing my business to from here on out. Mind u this was the 2nd time in a row I stopped there just that day so obviously I was a good customer.

Savanna Keiser 4 months ago

Great place to swing by for a slice! The staff was friendly and the pizza came out quick! I got the buffalo chicken with hot honey and the house made red pepper flakes! The slice was huge! It came out hot and the crust was crunchy but still had a nice chew and I enjoyed the blue cheese crumbles. The price was very reasonable, food was good, and it was the perfect weather for a slice outside so no issue with outside only seating!

Chris Evangelist 4 months ago

Marinas wouldn't let me pay cash for my order so I ended up at Shackamackas for the first time in 6 months and it has definitely evolved since my last visit. Much more variety in slices and at cheaper prices (buffalo chicken was $5.50). They've also improved the cook on them so they're not exploding into pizza dust as you crunch your way to the crust. I'll be back!

Jeffrey D 6 months ago

Walk up to the window and order a slice. No indoor shenanigans to sort out, although I wonder how it gets when detriment weather is about. Anyway, pizza was delicious. It was saucy, had a Garlicy crust and was well cooked, it checked all the boxes.

Mark Midmark a year ago

I've been wanting to come here for years, but I'm always getting food elsewhere in the area. Today I changed that. I went with the everything bagel pizza slice special, and a plain to see how their base is. Ordering is solely through a side window, with limited street seating. This is a place to get a slice and go. The special slice was creative, and the food came out pretty quickly. Approximately 5 minutes from ordering of two slices to receiving the food. Both slices were cooked nicely, and tasted pretty good. Neither stood out to me as memorable, but every bite was crunchy and flavorful. I like the little cheese pieces on top, and I finished the crusts of both. I'd probably stop here in the future if I was coming home from a bar, or wanted a quick slice when in the area. I don't drink anymore, and I usually am in the area with intent to eat somewhere already, so I won't likely be back any time soon. It's well worth your time and money, you may love it!